BY Steve Rudman 02:48PM 01/15/2014

Seahawks vs. 49ers: And the edge goes to . . .

Seahawks and 49ers are about as close statistically as two teams can be. Who has the edge Sunday? As the numbers suggest, both of them do.

San Francisco quarterback Colin Kaepernick struggled in his two appearances at CenturyLink Field.  / Drew McKenzie, Sportspress Northwest

San Francisco is the hottest team in the NFL playoffs. The 49ers have won eight in a row, five on the road, including a pair in the playoffs at Green Bay (23-20) and Carolina (23-10). While the 49ers are peaking at the right time, the Seahawks have flattened. They went 2-2 in their final four regular season games before defeating New Orleans 23-15 in a divisional playoff game that came closer than it should have to getting away.

But the NFC Championship will be played in Seattle, where the Seahawks have overwhelmed the 49ers the past two years. That would seem to give a significant edge to Seattle, but Arizona proved Dec. 22 it’s possible to silence the 12th Man by scuttling the Seahawks 17-10. Needing to beat San Francisco a week later at home to reach the postseason, the Cardinals couldn’t get it done, losing 23-20.

Seattle and San Francisco are about as evenly matched as can be. Within the context of league rankings, the Seahawks finished No. 8 in scoring offense, the 49ers No. 11. Seattle has the No. 1 scoring defense, San Francisco the No. 3.

In 16 regular-season games, Seattle scored 45 touchdowns, San Francisco 44. The Seahawks averaged 26.1 points, the 49ers 25.4. The Seahawks allowed an average of 14.4 points, the Niners 17.0. The Seahawks had more interceptions (28 to 18) and a better turnover differential (+20 to San Francisco’s +12), but the Niners were better against the run (95.9 to 101.6) and yielded fewer sacks (39 to Seattle’s 44). The tale of the tape (league ranks in parentheses):

Reg. Season Seahawks 49ers Skinny
Record 13-3 12-4 Seahawks No. 1 seed, 49ers No. 5
Total Off. 339.0 (17) 323.8 (24) Seahawks 5,424 yards, 49ers 5,180
Rush Off. 136.8 (4) 137.6 (3) M. Lynch 1,257 yards, F. Gore 1,128
Rush TDs 14 18 Lynch 12 (long 43), Gore 9 (long 51)
Pass Off. 202.3 (26) 186.2 (30) Wilson 101.2 rating, Kaepernick 91.6
Pass TDs 27 21 Wilson 26 (9 INTs), Kaepernick 21 (8)
Scoring Off. 26.1 (T8) 25.4 (11) Seahawks 417 points, 49ers 406
Off. TDs 45 44 Lynch 14, Vernon Davis 13 (all receive)
Total Def. 273.6 (1) 316.9 (5) Seahawks 4,378 yards, 49ers 5,071
Rush Def. 101.6 (T7) 95.9 (4) B. Wagner 120 tackles, N. Bowman 145
Rush TDs Allw. 4 11 Seahwks led NFL, 49ers ranked 11th
Pass Def. 172.0 (1) 221.0 (7) Seahawks 4.8 per attempt, 49ers 5.7
Pass TDs Allw. 16 19 Seahawks No. 2 in NFL, 49ers No. 5
Scoring Def. 14.4 (1) 17.0 (3) Seattle +186 scoring diff., 49ers +134
Def. TDs Allw. 22 30 49ers season-high 3 to Seattle Sept. 15
Times Sacked 44 39 Wilson sacked 44 times, Kaepernick 39
Sacks Made 44 38 Michael Bennett 8.5, Aldon Smith 8.5
INTs By 28 (1) 18 (T10) Richard Sherman 8, Tramaine Brock 5
Turnover Diff. +20 +12 Seahawks ranked 1st in NFL, 49ers 4th
Point Diff. +186 (2) +134 (3) Denver Broncos led NFL with +207

League rankings provide little illumination as to what will happen Sunday except to suggest it will be a close, low-scoring game, which is what most odds wizards are predicting. The head-to-head summary of the two previous games this season is no more enlightening in determining separation points between the top two teams in the NFC.

Seattle defeated San Francisco 29-3 at CenturyLink Sept. 15, and the 49ers prevailed 19-17 at Candlestick Park Dec. 8. But the games were closer than the point differential suggests.

Seattle’s 29-3 win turned on a first-quarter, end zone interception by Richard Sherman and a fourth-quarter pick by Kam Chancellor that set up Marshawn Lynch’s third touchdown. San Francisco’s 19-17 win hinged on one big play, a 51-yard run by Frank Gore that set up Phil Dawson’s game-winning field goal.

Otherwise, head-to-head it was this close: Seattle made 32 first downs, San Francisco 31. Seattle amassed 554 total yards, San Francisco 525. Seattle had a slight edge in passing yards, 296 to 262, but San Francisco had a narrow edge in rushing yards, 263 to 258. This is the two-game summary:

Category 49ers Seahawks
By Passing 15 16
By Rushing 13 11
By Penalties 3 5
3rd Downs 8-25 10-28
4th Downs 0-1 1-2
Yards Per Play 4.5 4.6
Total Drives 23 24
PASSING 262 296
Comp-Att 28-57 23-44
Yards Per Pass 4.55 6.65
INTs Thrown 4 2
Sacks-Yards Lost 5-40 6-45
RUSHING 263 258
Attempts 53 70
Yards Per Rush 4.96 3.68
RED ZONE 1-5 4-8
PENALTIES 19-191 19-169
Fumbles Lost 2 0
INTs Thrown 4 2

There’s not a dime’s worth of difference in there except turnovers, San Francisco committing six (four interceptions, two fumbles) to Seattle’s two (both interceptions).

So does either team have an edge Sunday? Well, yes and no.

EDGE 49ERS: Jim Harbaugh’s 49ers haven’t lost since Nov. 17 at New Orleans and permitted more than 20 points only once in that stretch (24 to Atlanta). They’re also more experienced in this position, with three straight NFC title-game appearances. None of the Seahawks have been here, most glaringly Russell Wilson, shaky in the divisional round.

EDGE SEAHAWKS: The Seahawks, 16-1 at CenturyLink the past two seasons, have not allowed more than 19 points in any of their past six games, averaging 11.2 per over that stretch.

EDGE 49ERS: San Francisco held five of its past six opponents to fewer than 100 yards rushing, which includes Marshawn Lynch and the Seahawks, who totaled 86 against the Niners in their last meeting Dec. 8.

EDGE SEAHAWKS: Lynch, who battered New Orleans for 140 yards and two TDs last Saturday, averages 105.3 yards against San Francisco at CenturyLink with four touchdowns in three games.

EDGE 49ERS: San Francisco features the league’s No. 4 rushing defense, greatly improved with the return of Aldon Smith.

EDGE SEAHAWKS: Lynch has rushed for a touchdown and caught a pass for a touchdown twice in the same game twice in his career and both came against the 49ers, on Dec. 23, 2012 and Sept. 15, 2013. Both games were at CenturyLink.

EDGE 49ERS: San Francisco’s front seven is littered with Pro Bowlers. In fact, 71 percent of the front seven has been selected to a Pro Bowl.

EDGE SEAHAWKS: The last two times the Seahawks and 49ers met at the Clink, Lynch combined for 209 yards rushing and three touchdowns.

EDGE 49ERS: Seattle’s offense has been stagnant lately, averaging 20 points per game over the last five.

EDGE SEAHAWKS: The Seahawks know how to pile up points against San Francisco at CenturyLink, outscoring the Niners 71-16 in the last two meetings, and 46-22 this season. No team put up more points on San Francisco this year than Seattle’s 29 Sept. 15.

EDGE 49ERS: San Francisco’s Colin Kaepernick has produced three postseason road wins as a starting quarterback, one last year, two this season (Green Bay and  Carolina). That’s more road playoff victories than the total by all other quarterbacks in 49ers history combined (excluding Super Bowls). The records of other San Francisco quarterbacks who started on the road in the playoffs: John Brodie, 1-1; Joe Montana, 1-3; Steve Young, 0-3; Jeff Garcia, 0-2.

EDGE SEAHAWKS: Total QB Rating grades quarterbacks on a 0-100 scale with 50 about average. By this metric, Kepernick has had two “below average” starts in his NFL career and both came in Seattle – 27.6 Dec. 23, 2012 in San Francisco’s 42-13 loss, and 14.0 in Week 2 this year in a 29-3 defeat. In the latter game, Kaepernick had a career-low NFL passer rating of 20.1. Also, Kaepernick has looked far more confused than confident in Seattle, where he has completed a combined 32 of 64 passes for 371 yards with one TD and four picks.

EDGE 49ERS: No NFC quarterback with more than 300 passing attempts threw fewer interceptions than Kaepernick’s eight. Since Week 12, Kaepernick has thrown 12 touchdowns vs. two interceptions and completed 59.7 percent of his throws.

EDGE SEAHAWKS: Seattle has intercepted 12 passes since Dec. 8, including five against the Giants and four vs. Arizona. The last time Seattle played San Francisco at CenturyLink, the Seahawks sacked Kaepernick twice, hit him twice and hurried him 14 times. During the regular season, the Seahawks held opposing quarterbacks to a league-low 63.4 passer rating. Seattle’s defense ranks No. 1 in passing yards and No. 1 in interceptions, a feat accomplished by only two other teams since the 1970 merger, Miami in 1982, Tampa Bay in 2002. Both teams reached the Super Bowl.

EDGE 49ERS: Although primarily a running team, the 49ers have expanded their passing game since the return of WR Michael Crabtree Dec. 1. Crabtree has averaged 14.95 yards per catch and opened things up for WR Anquan Boldin and TE Vernon Davis. Boldin caught eight passes for 136 yards last week against Carolina.

EDGE SEAHAWKS: Crabtree has never caught a touchdown pass at CenturyLink Field (four games).

EDGE 49ERS: Wilson’s early-season play placed him in the conversation for MVP, but he hasn’t looked like a franchise or even a Pro Bowl quarterback for five weeks. Wilson hasn’t thrown for more than 200 yards since Dec. 2, while the offense overall is averaging 266 total yards over the last five. During that span, the running game has also been limited to fewer than 90 yards per game, compared to 113 over the first 11.

EDGE SEAHAWKS: The Seahawks are talented enough to win even when Wilson is off his game. Wilson passed for 103 yards in Seattle’s victory over New Orleans last Saturday, marking the lowest passing-yardage total by a winning quarterback in any of the NFL’s last 41 postseason games, dating to when the Jets won at San Diego following the 2009 season with 93 passing yards. Wilson also defeated San Francisco earlier this season with a less-than-thrilling 63.9 passer rating.

EDGE 49ERS: Frank Gore is a Seahawks killer. He has rushed for 1,364 career yards against Seattle, his highest total against any NFL team. In that total are five 100-yard games, including a pair of 200-yard efforts, Nov. 19, 2006 (212) and Sept. 20, 2009 (207). When Gore broke a 51-yard non-scoring run against Seattle Dec. 8, setting up Phil Dawson’s game-winning, 22-yard field goal, he became the first opponent to produce five career 50-yard runs against the Seahawks. These are those runs:

  • Nov. 19, 2006: 51 yards (no TD) in a 20-14 San Francisco win.
  • Nov. 19, 2006: 50 yards (no TD) in the same game.
  • Sept. 20, 2009: 79-yard TD in a 23-10 San Francisco win.
  • Sept. 20, 2009: 80-yard TD in the same game.
  • Dec. 8, 2013: 51 yards (no TD) in San Francisco’s 19-17 win.

No other player has had more than two 50-yard runs against Seattle, and just two managed that. Denver’s Terrell Davis had a 70-yard non-scoring run Oct. 11, 1998, and a 57-yard non-scoring run Dec. 9, 2001. Tyrone Wheatley of Oakland scored an 80-yard TD Oct. 22, 2000 and had a 67-yard non-scoring run Dec. 16, 2000.

EDGE SEAHAWKS: None of Gore’s 50-yard runs occurred at CenturyLink Field. Gore has not produced a 100-yard rushing game in Seattle since 2006, and in his last two appearances at the Clink he has combined for 44 yards on 15 carries and zero touchdowns.

EDGE 49ERS: Aside from his big catch late against the Saints, Doug Baldwin has been MIA in recent weeks. Golden Tate has struggled to get open and Jermaine Kearse hasn’t caught more than three passes in a game all year.

EDGE SEAHAWKS: Percy Harvin has yet to be cleared to play (concussion), but the last time he faced San Francisco (Sept. 23, 2012), he caught NINE passes for 89 yards and returned three kickoffs 74 yards.

EDGE 49ERS: The Seahawks finished the season ranked No. 1 in the NFL in fewest points and yards allowed, but in all three of their losses, including a 19-17 defeat to San Francisco Dec. 8, they held a lead in the fourth quarter only to see it evaporate.

EDGE SEAHAWKS: The 49ers didn’t have leads to blow in three of their four losses, scoring three points at Seattle (29-3), seven vs. Indianapolis (27-7) and nine vs. Carolina (regular season).

EDGE 49ERS: Since Harbaugh followed Pete Carroll into the pros in 2011, the Niners have beaten Seattle four of six times. In those games, the 49ers have outscored Seattle 84-57.

EDGE SEAHAWKS: In Carroll’s two wins, both at home, the Seahawks have outscored the 49ers 71-16.

With all of that, we know two things for sure: The team that scores first in this rivalry usually wins (five out of eight times). And we know that the team that wins the rushing battle ALWAYS wins. Since Carroll took over in Seattle in 2010, the team that had a statistical edge in rushing is 8-0, as the chart shows:

Year Date Result SF Rush Sea Rush Rushing Leader / Yards
2010 Sept. 12 Sea 31-6 49 77 Justin Forsett (Sea), 43
Dec. 12 SF 40-21 95 84 Anthony Dixon (SF), 60
2011 Sept. 11 SF 33-21 85 64 Frank Gore (SF), 59
Dec. 24 SF 19-17 178 124 Marshawn Lynch (Sea), 107
2012 Oct. 18 SF 13-6 175 136 Frank Gore (SF), 131
Dec. 23 Sea 42-13 82 176 Marshawn Lynch (Sea), 111
2013 Sept. 15 Sea 29-3 100 172 Marshawn Lynch (Sea), 98
Dec. 8 SF 19-17 163 86 Frank Gore (SF), 110

If San Francisco hosted this game, it would be foolish to bet against the 49ers. But it’s in Seattle, where the Seahawks have a .688 winning percentage since 2002.



  • jafabian

    Seahawks win. In the playoffs the edge goes to whomever has homefield advantage and the better defense. If Kaepernick thinks the 12th Man is loud he hasn’t heard them in the playoffs. I’d say the Hawks are also the more focused team. They’ve made the Super Bowl their goal ever since the horn blew last year in Atlanta and they were reminded of that when they lost in SF, a game they could have and should have won. Just on defense alone I give the game to the Hawks.

    How do you know the California State Police are seriously enforcing the Speed Limits into San Francisco? For the first offense, they give you two 49ers tickets. If you get stopped a second time, they make you use them!

  • 1coolguy

    Great article Steve!
    In short, Niners have better receivers, hawks have better secondary. All else is a push.
    Sure hope the Hawks get a few big (6’3″+) receivers in the offseason so Russell has bigger targets.

    • jafabian

      Too bad the Hawks didn’t hold onto Stephen Williams. He’s 6-5″.