BY Howie Stalwick 09:59PM 11/01/2014

Halliday’s leg broken in Cougs’ 44-17 loss to USC

As if losing to USC 44-17 wasn’t bad enough, QB Connor Halliday needed surgery after the game to fix a broken leg. But Mike Leach was weirdly awkward about it.

Conner Hallliday, here against Rutgers, had his right leg broken after a clean hit by USC star Leonard Williams Saturday in Pullman. / Gary Breedlove, Sportspress Northwest

PULLMAN – So many times for so many years in so many games, Connor Halliday staggered to his feet after taking a vicious hit and kept on slingin’ footballs for Washington State. Halliday’s courage was as remarkable as his talent, not to mention his determination to revive the football program at the school he loves so much.

On Saturday afternoon, Halliday’s college football career almost certainly came to a crashing halt. Literally.

Halliday, the nation’s leading passer, never made it out of the first quarter. Right about the time USC was putting the wraps on the Cougars’ latest defeat, Halliday was undergoing surgery to fix the damage caused when 300-pound Leonard Williams gave the WSU senior a legal lick about one nanosecond after Halliday threw what figures to be the final pass of his remarkable 2014 season.

Various media reports said Halliday suffered a broken fibula in his right leg. WSU coach Mike Leach, who virtually never comments on injuries, would only confirm that Halliday underwent surgery of some sort. Reports that Leach specifically said Halliday leg surgery were incorrect. Leach refused to say if Halliday is done for the year, though a broken leg would obviously do the trick.

Lord knows no one else at WSU would dare comment on an injury. That’s a no-no under the Leach regime, and the coach – who can be alternately charming or abrasive – has intimidated more than a few folks during his three years in Pullman.

Leach’s ability to maintain such power figures to weaken if his rebuilding efforts at WSU do not soon start producing much better results. Obviously, the challenge grew immensely when Halliday went down.

“It’s a big hole in leadership there,” WSU center Sam Flor said. “He’s done a great job of leading the team this year.”

“Connor’s contributions to this program – most of them are ones the public doesn’t fully have appreciation,” Leach said. “His leadership and competitiveness.”

Halliday’s replacement Saturday, redshirt freshman Luke Falk, said he’s “pretty sure” he’ll be starting the final three games. Falk had thrown two passes all year before going 38 for 57 for 370 yards, two touchdowns and one interception in the 44-17 loss to USC.

“Connor and I have had a great relationship,” said Falk, a former walk-on. “He’s been my mentor here . . . my thoughts and prayers are out to him. He’s a great guy, and I really love him.”

That type of verbal expression is rare in the macho world of college football. Halliday, fiery and passionate, tends to spur that type of devotion from those around him. Flor, for example, seemed to be hurting emotionally every bit as much as Halliday was hurting physically after Flor was overpowered by Williams on the play where Halliday was injured.

“They did a twist on the (defensive) line,” Flor said solemnly, “and I just didn’t twist off fast enough. I got beat.”

Flor added, “I felt awful about it. I had a hand in that. All that’s on me.”

Flor takes no consolation in the fact that Williams is a ferocious pass rusher whose name is being bandied about as the possible No. 1 overall pick in next year’s NFL draft. Williams is simply better than Flor —  a redshirt sophomore making his second start — and there were similar mismatches all over the field Saturday.

The Cougars have proven beyond any doubt they are too young, inexperienced and mentally fragile to succeed on a regular basis. Saturday’s game simply provided more proof.

“We’re just too up and down emotionally as far as good play, bad play,” Leach said. “We’re all over the map.”

WSU’s fourth consecutive loss officially eliminated the Cougars (2-7, 1-5 Pac-12) from bowl consideration. Three games are left in what is now certain to be Washington State’s eighth losing season in a row. That streak would be 11 if not for a 6-6 season in 2006.

Even the Cougars, the traditional conference whipping boys, never previously put together eight consecutive losing seasons. Leach’s Cougars may not be Paul Wulff bad – remember that 69-0 home loss to USC in 2008, when then-Trojans coach Pete Carroll did everything but start himself at tailback to keep his team from beating the previous head coach’s sorry crew even worse? – but they’re in the ballpark.

The Cougars give up way too many points, way too many yards, way too many big plays. They also have way too many letdowns in execution, focus and grit.

Want proof? The Cougars have been outscored 90-41 in the first quarter this year, including 38-0 the past two weeks. One week after the Cougars gave up 59 points and five touchdown passes to an Arizona team with a redshirt freshman quarterback, they gave up 44 points and five touchdown passes to a USC team with three freshmen starting on the offensive line. USC returned a punt for a touchdown, the sixth punt or kickoff returned for a touchdown against WSU in five games.

The simple fact is, USC’s young players are better than WSU’s young players, and USC’s older players are better than WSU’s older players. Senior Vince Mayle, one of the nation’s leading receivers, was one of several Cougars who dropped passes Saturday that were right on target.

“They hit guys right in the chest, hands, guts,” Leach muttered. “If they were bullets, they would have killed them.”

The Cougars, of course, have rolled over and played dead against the Trojans for years. Aside from last year’s ugly 10-7 win at Los Angeles, when Lane Kiffin was spending his final days in charge of the asylum that passed for USC’s locker room, the Cougars seem to have been losing to the Trojans forever. Unfortunately for the Cougars, a loss to USC just mixes in seamlessly with all the losses to other teams these days.


  • foulkeyu

    What tripe.

  • Big

    The unvarnished truth.

  • Random_acct

    I don’t care if our win over USC last season was “ugly”. We still won.

    That was so long ago though.

  • RadioGuy

    This stinks. As hard as I’ve been on Halliday here and elsewhere, he was turning my thinking about him around this year because it’s pretty apparent the guy is a competitor who hates to lose, which tells me it’s not all about the numbers with him. I hope he recovers from his broken leg and gets a fair shot in the NFL or CFL next year.

    It’s becoming pretty apparent, if it wasn’t already, that even with a big-name coach and facility upgrades, Washington State just can’t compete at the PAC 12 level. I truly do love the Cougs, believe it or not, but it’s getting really old knowing that we’re trying to counter Uzis with .38 Specials in almost every conference game. But, hey, we’ll always have Utah.

    • Big

      Putting should’a, would’a, could’a aside, the Cougs had the opportunities to have 4 or 5 wins at this point in the season. The team and coaches have lost winnable games with youth, inexperience, dumb play, and poor decisions . Some players will walk after this season, none of the coaches deserve a rise or contract extension. The team needs more leadership from players and coaches, esp. from Leach. That said, go Cougs.

      • Its onlySports(DavidWakefield)

        The Way the coaching staff gave away that bowl game last season it was hard for me to approach this season with bursting enthusiasm and unfortunately coaches have shown lapses in competency again this year too. Now their record setting QB is down. Its a trifle depressing. Im sure coug fans would take consecutive ugly wins to close out the season strong but its hard to believe it will happen at this point. One thing for sure. That talk about Leach being wildly successful and using Pulman as a springing board(soon) to a big time program? Aint gonna happen.

  • Effzee

    I’m not sure you can win with Leach’s system when you don’t have University of Oklahomo or State of Texas talent. Even if you can find guys who can run fast and score a lot of points, you’re going to score them quickly, and you still have to get good enough defensive talent and depth to spend most of the game on the field. I think there are places you can succeed with this type of system (Oklahomo, Baylor, Texas Tech, etc.) I just don’t think you can completely ignore the running game, and rely on your defense only to keep you in games, while focusing all your efforts on setting passing records. Not at Wazzu anyways. If I had the choice of running Chip Kelly’s offense or Mike Leach’s offense, I would choose Kelly’s every time. You just can’t ignore the running game and win big. You just can’t do it. If Leach wants to prove that he can, he’s going to need to head back to the South, where he can scrape more talent off the Texas reject pile than he could pay to come to Pullman.