BY Andrew Harvey 12:00AM 11/08/2016

NFL admits referee errors in field goal debacle

The Seahawks were beneficiaries of a pair of officiating mistakes: A missed call of unnecessary roughness on Richard Sherman, followed by a mismanaged play clock that cost the Bills a critical field goal.

The Seahawks defense got to Bills QB Tyrod Taylor for five sacks, including this one from Cliff Avril  half. / Drew Sellers, Sportspress Northwest

As a record 69,084 at CenturyLink Field Monday night howled, the Seahawks-Bills game entered the twilight zone at the end of the first half. Three seconds stretched into several minutes of embarrassing confusion in a sequence that cost the Bills three crucial points in a 31-25 Seahawks victory.

After Buffalo QB Tyrod Taylor completed a pass up the middle to WR Robert Woods at the Seattle 35-yard line, the Bills took their final timeout of the half with three seconds left. Trailing 28-17, coach Rex Ryan sent out the field goal unit, hoping to have a one-score game on his hands when his team received the second half kickoff.

Things went awry in bizarre fashion, in a way that left many blowing the dust off rule books.

On the initial field goal attempt, Seahawks CB Richard Sherman rushed off the edge before the ball was snapped, surging toward Bills kicker Dan Carpenter. The ball was snapped anyway as whistles blew for the offsides penalty, and Sherman dove to block the kick. His momentum carried him into the plant leg of Carpenter, who writhed on the ground in pain after his knee appeared to hyper-extend.

Referee Walt Anderson turned on his microphone to address the crowd:

“Prior to the snap, offside, defense, No.  25, unabated to the kicker, it’s a five-yard penalty.”

Then came the whammy:

“Trainers came out to attend to No. 2 (Carpenter). This will be a fourth charged timeout from Buffalo. No. 2 will have to leave the game” for at least one play.

Cheers came from the crowd as a flock of Seahawks jogged toward the tunnel. Anderson spoke with the panic of a high school teacher whose students bolted before class was dismissed:

“The half is not over!”

Inside of two minutes, teams are allowed a free fourth timeout if an injured player needs medical attention. A fifth timeout for the same reason draws a delay of game penalty and 10-second runoff, which inspired the Seahawks and Bills to leave for intermission.

Seattle wasn’t the only group to misinterpret the rules. The NFL admitted that Anderson’s assessment of a mere offside was insufficient for Sherman’s hit on Carpenter.

NFL VP of officiating Dean Blandino said Sherman deserved a flag for unnecessary roughness.

“We looked at it and it is a foul,” Blandino said. “It is no different than a defender coming offside and hitting a quarterback after the whistle blew, so it should have been unnecessary roughness.

“(Anderson) in looking at it was coming in to kill to play and didn’t think the contact was enough. Obviously when you look at the tape, that is not the case.”

Anderson explained his rationale after the game: The clock never started, since the play was blown dead once Sherman charged into the backfield.

“I just didn’t feel like the actions and the contact, because we were shutting the play down, warranted a foul,” Anderson said. “One of the things we’re looking for is, does the player have a chance to realize that we’re shutting the play down and whether or not he has an opportunity to avoid any type of contact.”

After players from both sides returned, the Bills were left with a problem:  Three seconds to run a play on first and five, with Carpenter forced to sit for a play.

Bills head coach Rex Ryan took a sword to the Gordian knot, electing to send Taylor out to spike the ball and burn a play, and two seconds, so Carpenter could return.

Taylor’s spike sparked another bizarre turn. The use of a regular-play football for the spike meant that it had to be swapped out for a kicking ball. As a referee stood over the ball to do the swap and allow extra time for defensive substitutions, the play clock errantly dwindled as officials conversed.

By the time the Bills were allowed to get over the ball, four seconds remained on the play clock.

They didn’t get the snap away in time and drew a flag for delay of game as the ball moved through the uprights. The Bills were moved back to the 35-yard line for a 52-yard field goal attempt instead of 47-yard attempt, or the 35-yarder they would have had if Sherman were assessed a roughness penalty.

Anderson admitted this was a mistake.

“If there was that little time left, then that’s probably a mistake on my part in terms of not pumping the play clock up,” he said. “I was not aware that it was that far into the play clock.”

The 20-yard difference was everything. Carpenter’s kick missed wide right. The Bills went into halftime trailing by eight points.

Ryan was perturbed.

“Ridiculous . . . absolutely ridiculous,” he said, red in the face. “I think from an officiating stand point I think they can do a little better than that.

“It doesn’t matter (about the explanation), it was wrong.”

The missing three points affected the game’s final moments. Trailing by six instead of three, the Bills boomed down the field to a first and goal at the Seattle 9. But the Seahawks sacked him twice and his fourth down pass fell incomplete, allowing Seattle to run out the clock.

Ryan would have loved to have needed only three to tie and force overtime.

“Of course,” Ryan said. “We had all the momentum, we were outplaying them. That was clear.”

Blandino said the league will “absolutely” address the officiating errors. But there’s no erasing the black eyes on the Monday showcase game for a national audience searching for amusement amid the political angst.



  • ll9956

    This was the second game in a row that was marred by inexcusable failures of the officials. Against New Orleans the Hawks were victimized. This time it was Buffalo that was the victim. The umpire standing over the ball until there were only 4 seconds left on the play clock was a disaster. If Sherman had been called for unnecessary roughness, I believe that would have given Buffalo a first down. That could have affected the outcome of the game, just as the no-calls against New Orleans very likely changed the outcome of that game.

    These officials need to be eliminated from post-season games and possibly not be invited back next year.

  • Talkjoc

    It appeared to me that Sherman touched, but didn’t disrupt the spot of the field goal attempt and then crashed into the kicker. Isn’t it a rule that if you touch the ball you can make contact? The rest is crazy. Thinking the league will be forced to make refs full-time employees. Art, your take on the touching the ball rule. Thanks as always.

    • Eric K

      Yeah, I thought the refs made two mistakes, initially they didn’t blow the play dead as unabated, since they didn’t Sherman was right to finish the play, and once he hit the ball it wasn’t roughing.

      But then they really messed up the play clock so there shouldn’t have been a delay.

      Then .Blandino can’t even explain the errors correctly, and by the way since when does he tweet about calls during games? Even when they admit to blown calls like the Saints game last week they never actually say anything publicly.

      The Bills are right to be mad. But you can’t just assume that the 2nd half plays out the same, both teams may make different play calls with a different score.

      • Rosaliadbrown

        Google is paying 97$ per hour! Work for few hours and have longer with friends & family! !mj191d:
        On tuesday I got a great new Land Rover Range Rover from having earned $8752 this last four weeks.. Its the most-financialy rewarding I’ve had.. It sounds unbelievable but you wont forgive yourself if you don’t check it
        ➽➽;➽➽ http://GoogleFinancialJobsCash191TopShopGetPay$97Hour ★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★::::::!mj191d:….,……

      • Karlalbenjamin

        Google is paying 97$ per hour! Work for few hours and have longer with friends & family! !mj163d:
        On tuesday I got a great new Land Rover Range Rover from having earned $8752 this last four weeks.. Its the most-financialy rewarding I’ve had.. It sounds unbelievable but you wont forgive yourself if you don’t check it
        ➽➽;➽➽ http://GoogleFinancialJobsCash163TopUSAGetPay$97Hour ★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★::::::!mj163d:….,…..

  • bugzapper

    One more thing: In his zeal to ensure Sherman got penalized, Carpenter pulled a Full Fred Brown Flop. “OW, MY KNEE! LET ME WRITHE ON THE GROUND FOR A FEW SECONDS!” Then he pops up like there’s nothing wrong and his kicking leg is just fine.

    If he hadn’t tried to pull that stunt he wouldn’t have had to leave the game for a play. Thus, the screw-up over the expiring play clock would never have happened.

    Btw, this is the second straight Seahawks game that came down to an incomplete pass in the end zone on the final play. I’m all for drama, but dominant Seahawks teams on the last few years never let it get that far. They put teams away. Early.

    Finally, I was astonished at how often everyone, including Pete at the post-game presser, claimed Russell is so much more mobile now. F’ing ridiculous! My grandmama could have run him down last night! Think about that play in the first half when he ran for a first down. A mobile, healthy Russell could have easily made another five yards on the play and still have time to slide and not be hit. We have no ground game if he can’t run, and it shows.

    • jafabian

      Notice that Carpenter waved off the trainer when he came out. IMO that’s because he knew by coming out onto the field he’d have to be pulled off the field but it was too late. His FIFA worthy performance backfired on him.

      Sherman is not only getting raked over the coals for rolling into Carpenter (And IMO Sherman did the right thing: the whistle wasn’t blown, you keep playing) but also for laying out Woods on the last play. People fail to notice (Chris Collinsworth among them) that Taylor left the pocket. When that happens the WR becomes a blocker. Sherman wisely took out Woods to take out of the play and it looked obvious that he was the red zone target.

      • John M

        I had not noticed that block, good take. Sherm should not have been flagged for roughness if the whistle hadn’t blown and he touched the ball first, which it appeared happened. He wasn’t seeing anything but his play . . .

        • jafabian

          Say what you will about Richard, he’s one of the most intelligent players in the game right now. He knows the rules book inside and out and what he can and can’t do. He was watching both Woods and Taylor at the same time and as soon as Taylor was flushed out of the pocket BAM!! He nailed Woods. Right there the game was over.